Account
    Help
    Blog
    Cake Card
    SpongeSponge Logo
    Club
    • 0items in cart, view bag

    Sticky Toffee Cake

    A decadent sticky toffee pudding cake crafted with a home-made date puree and filled with smooth toffee buttercream.

    Product no longer available.
    This product is no longer available. Why not try one of our alternative products?

    Our Sticky Toffee Pudding Cake is a twist on the Great British Classic. Our home-made date puree with treacle and syrup creates the most comfortingly sticky Sponge which is held together with a warming toffee butter cream. It's an irrisistable treat for toffee lovers. 

    read more...

    Packaging

    • Check markRecyclable packaging
    • Check markSecure outer box
    • Check markBio-degradable film
    • Check markUK wide delivery available
    • Check markCreate the perfect gift with personalisation extras
    • Check markCutting guide included for the perfect portion size

    Storage & Care

    • Check markAllow the cake to come to room temperature before eating, the butter cream shouldn't be hard!
    • Check markOnce opened, store at room temperature in an air tight container.
    • Check markLeftovers? Occasion not for a few days? Keep wrapped and store in the freezer for up to 6 months.
    • Check markUse our included cutting guide for the generous portion size
    • Check markKeep uncovered as it will dry out
    • Check markEat the cake straight out of the fridge or freezer - the cakes needs to be up to room temperature.
    • Check markLeave cakes in direct sunlight as the butter icing may melt.
    • Check markLeave unattended near kids, as the temptation will be too much!

    Ingredients & allergens

    +

    Sugar, water, self raising flour (wheat flour, raising agents (sodium bicarbonate, mono calcium phosphate), calcium carbonate, iron, niacin, thiamin), margarine (palm oil, rapeseed oil, salt, emulsifier E475, flavouring, sunflower oil, colours (curcumin, annatto), dates, eggs, butter (milk), golden syrup, treacle, raising agent (sodium bicarbonate), natural vanilla flavour, natural toffee flavour.

    ALLERGENS IN BOLD. Made in a kitchen which handles eggs, nuts, milk, soya & sulphites.

    Reviews

    • Not a lover myself but sent to nephew recently - top marks
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      JACQUELINE B - 17/04/2025
    • Sweet but not overly so, gorgeous
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Karen M - 16/04/2025
    • Beautiful sticky toffee flavour people were raving about them
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Karen Lesley B - 04/03/2025
    • Absolutely delicious! Tasted great on its on and also heated up with custard!
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Alice A - 23/02/2025
    • The sponge was light and moist with a lovely taste of sticky toffee pudding.
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Emma G - 02/02/2025
    • this was another one that was a hit
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Julie H - 21/01/2025
    • Classic and delicious, could never go wrong with a toffee pud.
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Daria W - 05/01/2025
    • A lovely gift for Christmas with my family member delighted with her cute little cakes
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Ann B - 26/12/2024
    • Great
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Angela K - 26/10/2024
    • Had this as it’s my daughter’s Birthday as it’s her favourite. Delivered fast and great quality as always
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Sarah W - 29/09/2024
    • ditto
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Lesley A - 21/09/2024
    • Absolutely gorgeous such a lovely flavour to get in a cake and if you've got some leftover why not warm it and cover in a little ice-cream for a tasty sweet treat.
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Peter K - 29/08/2024
    • This is my boyfriends favourite so I bought it for his birthday and he was overjoyed when I gave it to him. It did not disappoint, everyone said it was tasty without being too rich and it has the right amount of flavour in the sponge to bring out the lovely taste of the filling. A great birthday cake choice!
      Large Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Karen D - 29/08/2024
    • Perfect for those with a sweet tooth.
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Martin S - 01/07/2024
    • Delicious!
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Jacinta G - 20/06/2024
    • Loved them just right
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Lesley J - 15/06/2024
    • Everyone who had a piece of this cake, gave it the thumbs up
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Gail T - 27/05/2024
    • I think this is a Favourite one to be ordered again
      Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge
      Jean S - 03/05/2024
    • Very delicious and addictive 😋
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Lorraine W - 13/04/2024
    • Dad said it was very tasty
      Medium Sticky Toffee Pudding
      Michael M - 09/04/2024

    You might also like...

    • Choose Your Own Baby Sponge Cakes

      Choose Your Own Baby Sponge Cakes

    • Apple Crumble Cake

      Apple Crumble Cake

    • Chocolate & Caramel

      Chocolate & Caramel

     
    More information

    Our special twist on the Great British Classic of Sticky Toffee pudding, is great for all occasions! Sticky Toffee Pudding Sponge is perfect for cuddling up with by the fire. It is also delicious warmed up with cream or custard poured all over it for the ultimate treat! Great for helping you to warm up in the colder months, although can be enjoyed at anytime throughout the year.

    Personalise your order by adding balloons, candles, greeting cards, drinks and more. To create the perfect celebration cake, ready for any occasion! We have a great selection of caards that can go on your Sticky Toffee Sponge. Including Happy Birthday ones, Christening, Anniversary, and children's ones! Designs include unicorns, princesses, dinosaurs, diggers, fairies, and mermaids. There is something for everyone!

    STORAGE - Please store me in an air-tight container in a cosy spot - I don't like being kept in the fridge. Can be frozen for up to 6 months.

    More Information

    • Help / Contact Us
    • Sponge Story
    • Delivery
    • Returns / Refunds
    • Blog
    • Charity Partnerships
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy & Cookies
    • Reset My Session

    Join our mailing list

    Sign up for exclusive offers, new products, competitions and news from Sponge, plus 10% off your first order.

    Our Accreditations

    Vegan SocietyCoeliac UK

    Follow us

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn

    Accepted payment methods

    • Apple Pay
    • Google Pay
    • VISA
    • Mastercard
    Sponge Cakes Ltd
    Holt Woodlands, Hempstead Road, Holt, Norfolk, NR25 6DG
    © 2025 Sponge Cakes Ltd

    Sponge (and selected third parties) uses cookies and other technologies to improve your experience and for personalised ads & content. More Info.